If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
Yes. It is important for everyone to remember to preserve the
dignity of those who are forced by circumstances to accept aid. I only donate that which I would actually wear myself, if I was thinner, or fatter, or had more room in my closet!! I also try to present donations in a neat and pleasing manner. PAT in VA/USA Don/Gen wrote: Thank you for writing this. I get so angry when I see all the junk people pawn off on others in need. I keep thinking of the huge pile of clothing on the beach after hurricane Andrew, that eventually was plowed under when it became moldy and varmint infested. How much better it would have been for people to give it to a re-sale place, and have them donate money. There was a picture in the paper today of a pile of shoes and clothes along a road in MS. How degrading for the survivors to have to pick through that mess. People just want to help, often without thinking about what they're doing. Gen |
Ads |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
I had one of those supervisors that we all called "Ms. Clueless'. We were
brainstorming in a staff meeting about what to include in case plans in order to reunite neglected (that usually means filth and crud for the uninformed) kids with their families that could help them remain in the home. Social Workers use the term "Successful Reunification". This particular supervisor rarely ever made home visits and had been "appointed" to her position by the governor (of Missouri, Leslie). She had made her first home visit all by herself the day before and was still in shock from the experience. She had drove her very luxerious BMW and had walked into this cockroach ridden home with filth and crud everywhere on her 3 inch pointy toed designer heels. She was appalled at the fact the mother was "depressed" and reported to the staff how she berated the lady about getting off the couch and getting a job to make money. Then she drummed her perfectly manicured nails on the table and said: " I mean ... really ... why wouldn't she want to buy some new furniture or something!" We all put our face in our coffee at the same instant and chocked - out loud - all at the same time. I couldn't breathe for fear I would laugh. Sorry you had the bad experience of having a similarly clueless social worker. I too came from a family of poverty but we were blessed with parents who taught a strong work ethic, pride and a belief that education was the way out. My Daddy earned $100 month as a school bus driver. He parked the bus at our house at the end of the day because we had no car so he couldn't drive to work. The whole family worked for others in their farms to earn a little cash and we took care of our own little farm to raise some of our food needs. We relied on others to drive us to town or to the doctor. We had no electricity and our water came from a spring down the road. My mother made her own soap from lard and lye and I learned to iron with heavy irons heated on our wood cookstove. Laundry was boiled in a large cast iron pot and rubbed on a wash board (that I still have). We hung the clothes on the line and the sun dried them. The same tub that we rinsed the clean laundry in was used on Saturday night for a bathtub. My mother sewed our clothing from feedsacks and we got one pair of shoes a year from the Sears & Roebuck catalog just before school started. When the soles got holes in them they were lined with cardboard and if you out grew them Daddy cut a hole in the ends. We used an outhouse for a bathroom and the last years edition of the Sears & Roebuck Catalog was our toilet paper. So I know poverty first hand and I think it made me a better Social Worker. I knew the difference between Poverty and Neglect. Poor Ms. Clueless is married to the Chief of Police with her one son and still hasn't a clue about how the poorest in our community live and survive. -- http://community.webshots.com/user/snigdibbly SNIGDIBBLY ~e~ " / \ http://members.ebay.com/aboutme/snigdibbly. http://www.ebaystores.com/snigdibbly...ox&refid=store "NightMist" wrote in message ... On Tue, 6 Sep 2005 08:47:30 -0500, "SNIGDIBBLY" wrote: For years I was one of the coordinators for the County Community Share Xmas program where we accepted donated Xmas gifts and clothing for Foster Kids and poor kids across the county. I have seen so much waste and abuse. Parents sold the stuff for drugs and alcohol or just threw it out. I found brand new - unwrapped toys - in the garbage during home visits. Many parents signed up for like programs from every agency in the area and got duplicate food baskets and toys and sold them or just threw them out. I will never give a whole turkey dinner again unless I give a cooked turkey because they would let it spoil before they would cook it. There just doesn't seem to be any appreciation for the effort. Most wouldn't even come pick them up and our social workers would have to deliver them or they wouldn't get to the children at all. I have become too cynical. But I enjoy the giving so I do it with the knowledge that it probably won't be used as I wished it to be. I just have to let it go and enjoy the giving. Sure makes me made when people use other people and then abuse their charitible hearts. Snigs, I am not going to even try to excuse the a***oles of the world, because there is no excuse for them. There are indeed plenty of them, on both sides of the giving equation. It is high time some common sense was thrown into the world of charitable giving. Now, so you all know, I give when and what I can when causes come to my attention. More often though, my family and I are on the other side. Yes, we are poor. In fact, one of the jokes is we are "p", 'cause we can't afford the rest of the letters. I know that there are others out there that are much worse off than we are. In fact sometimes I get ****ed off because I know that there are needier people living close by and some charity comes knocking at my door (figuratively and sometimes literally) instead. I usually try to send them in the right direction, but often they are set on who they are going to give to. In my time, we have been gifted with food, clothes, and whatnot, and most of it was about as useful as tits on a boar hog. I have never thrown perfectly good things away, I have always tried to find someone else who needs them, or recycled them into a charitable organization. For example, one of the local churches (unasked) once brought us a turkey dinner for Thanksgiving. Delivered complete with conversion pitch and admonitions about how we were going to go straight to hell if we didn't give up sex, drugs, rock and roll, and our obviously satanic lifestyle. I guess that since we don't have a lot of money that means we are obviously maniacal drug useing minions of satan. Well even if we weren't vegetarians I didn't have the equipment to cook a damn turkey. What the heck was I supposed to do with the thing even if I planned on eating it? Stick it on a fork and toast it over a burner? Put it in the oven in a plastic grocery sack? I'm not even sure it would have fit in my oven. So I gave most of the lot to lady down the road. Even there I had to call the Salvation Army and beg a tinfoil roasting pan for her (she didn't have a phone, and was about as inclined to put her hand out as cut it off). Fortunately they not only gave her the pan but included a whole roll of tinfoil and instructions on how to cook the thing, otherwise she had no better idea of what to do with it than I did. Yeah, "Aunt Sal-ly" rocks! Another time a social worker gave me a bag of 8 or 9 brand new dresses for my then second grader. She thought they would be so cute with tights and rumba pants. Yeah, right. I have never, nor will I ever send a 7 year old child out into January in what amounts to a frilly shirt and stockings. Nor am I inclined to send a 7 year old girl out in a dress that flashes her bottom regardless, even if I could have forced her out the door dressed like that. To say nothing of the fact that I would have had to buy the rumba pants and then a never ending series of tights. (1) The dresses when to Aunt Sal-ly. The number of people who have thought that we would be so grateful to get their trash that we would come and fetch it is astounding. Anytime someone says, 'our widget is broken so we got a new one, but your husband is clever and I am sure he could fix the broken one. Just come and pick it up anytime between noon and 12:01.' I just smile, nod, and walk away. I don't have a car and I am not inclined to walk over to fetch a widget that I have been doing quite well without, and that probably will never work again anyway. There have been times that people have offered me large items that we really did truly need. But we haven't had the means to go fetch them. That has not been good. Especially when they get all angry because they know we need the thing. What the heck am I supposed to do? Pull a carjacking on a moving van? Remember the thread we had on kitchen stoves not long ago? Just last month I was darn near to weeping with frustration because my daughter's landlord offered us an old Chambers gas range in beautiful condition. He had taken on a partner who owned a second hand appliance store and was replaceing all the very old appliances in his apartments with more modern ones. I met this stove, it was beautiful. One of the ones the gas company gave out decades ago to get people to switch from wood or coal to gas. But I didn't have the fifty dollars the partner wanted to shift it, nor could I find anybody to move it for less. My stove is an apartment sized thing with one working burner, one sometimes working burner, and no functional pilots so I have to light the oven from the broiler. I sooo wanted that stove! I s'pose all I am saying is please please think before you give, and think before you condem. That social worker with the dresses gave us no end of grief about DD not wearing them, and other people have gone all superior, taking a "see what happens when you try to do good" attitude when we have not been all happy to recieve useless stuff or able to fetch things we actually needed. If you give a box of tuna helper to the food pantry, please give a couple of cans of tuna with it. Don't assume people will be happy to haul your junk for free just because they are poor. Please don't offer people things without a thought for how they will get them home. That is just cruel, especially if it is something they need. Don't assume that just because they are poor children will be happy with any old thing you want to give them. No ten year old will be happy with a toy meant for a toddler, regardless. Don't assume that everyone knows how to alter clothes that don't fit. Don't get all offended if they do alter clothes that don't fit. Most poor people do not need cable converters, entertainment centers, knick knacks, table linens, or cordless phones. I have been offered all of the above and turned down all but the linens, they were real linen and made some mighty fine shirts, but most people wouldn't know to do that with them. The lady with the cable converter was astounded that I didn't accept it and run right out to get cable. Please! Please! Please! Do not patronize or proselytize. Poor people have as much pride as anyone else. Being given a sermon along with food is something that you can expect at a mission, but not in your own home or at a secular help agency. It is wonderful to try and help the less fortunate. It is not wonderful to expect them to fall down and praise you for it. It is not wonderful to get all huffy when things you give do not get used as you anticipated. NightMist We are doing a whole lot better than we used to. (1) This was a worker who was offended for my child because this child was going to school in hand sewn and made over clothes, of which DD had plenty. -- "To repeat what others have said, requires education; to challenge it, requires brains." -Mary Pettibone Poole |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
SNIGDIBBLY wrote:
I knew the difference between Poverty and Neglect. Poor Ms. Clueless is married to the Chief of Police with her one son and still hasn't a clue about how the poorest in our community live and survive. Oh, dear! That did make me giggle! But had poor Mrs Clueless never TRAINED as a social worker? Did she know nothing of the depths to which depression can lead? It's an illness. People with depression need help, sometimes to do the simplest of things (and think about it - bathing kids ain't simple!). Maybe she should start by talking to the guys who work for her husband... My Little Sis is an inspector with the Metropolitan Police over here in London. She makes graveyard jokes about her job, and what they call 'the sticky carpet brigade' - where you scrape the muck off your shoes on the way OUT! As she says, sometimes you have to make the jokes or live there yourself. Being a member of the BTDT brigade in my own profession (I'm a dyslexic teacher of English) does give you some insight into the problems of others. It's very hard to keep a place clean in a building full of cockroaches, where the water and sewerage are sub-standard, and where one has no transport and the local shops are all charging the highest prices for soap and washing powder because they cannot compete with the out of town emporia for their own rent and business rates. It's not use saying 'get it fixed' when the washer breaks down through old age and slavery, and one hasn't the available dosh to buy new or reconditioned, or pay the guy to fix the old one. Add depression to the mix, and it's no wonder the house is a **** heap and the kids are neglected. And folk who are brought up in those circumstances can perpetuate them simply because they know no alternative... AKK! I need to get off this soap box and punt it into touch! Back to the sewing room for another round with the bridal hems... I feel so lucky that DH earns the bread and butter, and I can earn the occasional bit of cake! And I feel lucky that I CAN donate the unwanted stuff to others so that they can make good use of items that still have several miles in them. Oh, and I hoovered the carpet TWICE this week - but even the Dyson won't pick up cat whiskers that have woven themselves into the pile! And does anyone have any tips for removing porridge from fur? -- Kate XXXXXX R.C.T.Q Madame Chef des Trolls Lady Catherine, Wardrobe Mistress of the Chocolate Buttons http://www.katedicey.co.uk Click on Kate's Pages and explore! |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
"But had poor Mrs Clueless never TRAINED as a social worker?"
A person can feel "sympathy" for those less fortunate, they can be trained to deal with behaviors and attitudes - but I honestly do not believe that you can "train" empathy for people in this situation. I don't believe people can honestly understand what it is truly like, unless they have lived it themselves. I know too many people in this area that think just giving a "hand out" or writing a check should be all it takes to help the less fortunate. It's not! For one thing, when I was in this position, I was at times too proud and other times too ashamed to accept money from other people. I wanted to be able to do for myself and provide for my own children without accepting "charity" from others. I was more than willing to work and when I was married to the worthless, abusive alcoholic, I worked three jobs most of the time. There is an old saying that goes something like, "give me a hand UP, not a hand OUT" - this is exactly how I felt during those times. I didn't want to be pitied. I didn't want peoples leftovers. I didn't want to be treated like I was "less than a person" just because I didn't have as nice of clothes as they did or because I sewed my kids clothes. I didn't appreciate being looked down on just because I worked three jobs and when I was at home, I sat on the floor and played with my kids instead of volunteering at church or school or making sure our home was immaculate and kept up with the Jones'es. No, you can't "train" the understanding and the empathy that comes with not having. You can't "train" the mindset that goes along with learning to survive without. You have to live it to believe it. Tina |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
I think we can all say we have met college idiots but this pathetic lady
didn't have a degree. She was a political appointee. She didn't last long. She went on to ... er, bigger and better things ... if you know what I mean. LOL!! Something more appropriate for her professional wardrobe. I was in Rural Social Work with families for over 30 years and I never got used to the "sticky floors" and I will always remember this one mother who addressed her cockroach problem by lining all her cabinets with that tacky fly paper. She was so proud when she opened her cabinets and there was gadzillions of squirming cockroaches stuck to the fly paper. I thought I would loose it for sure that time and I have a pretty strong stomach. I kept my face straight (with a lot of effort) and praised her for being creative and utilitzing available resources to deal with problems like this. I aught to write a book but no one would believe it. LOL -- http://community.webshots.com/user/snigdibbly SNIGDIBBLY ~e~ " / \ http://members.ebay.com/aboutme/snigdibbly. http://www.ebaystores.com/snigdibbly...ox&refid=store "Kate Dicey" wrote in message ... SNIGDIBBLY wrote: I knew the difference between Poverty and Neglect. Poor Ms. Clueless is married to the Chief of Police with her one son and still hasn't a clue about how the poorest in our community live and survive. Oh, dear! That did make me giggle! But had poor Mrs Clueless never TRAINED as a social worker? Did she know nothing of the depths to which depression can lead? It's an illness. People with depression need help, sometimes to do the simplest of things (and think about it - bathing kids ain't simple!). Maybe she should start by talking to the guys who work for her husband... My Little Sis is an inspector with the Metropolitan Police over here in London. She makes graveyard jokes about her job, and what they call 'the sticky carpet brigade' - where you scrape the muck off your shoes on the way OUT! As she says, sometimes you have to make the jokes or live there yourself. Being a member of the BTDT brigade in my own profession (I'm a dyslexic teacher of English) does give you some insight into the problems of others. It's very hard to keep a place clean in a building full of cockroaches, where the water and sewerage are sub-standard, and where one has no transport and the local shops are all charging the highest prices for soap and washing powder because they cannot compete with the out of town emporia for their own rent and business rates. It's not use saying 'get it fixed' when the washer breaks down through old age and slavery, and one hasn't the available dosh to buy new or reconditioned, or pay the guy to fix the old one. Add depression to the mix, and it's no wonder the house is a **** heap and the kids are neglected. And folk who are brought up in those circumstances can perpetuate them simply because they know no alternative... AKK! I need to get off this soap box and punt it into touch! Back to the sewing room for another round with the bridal hems... I feel so lucky that DH earns the bread and butter, and I can earn the occasional bit of cake! And I feel lucky that I CAN donate the unwanted stuff to others so that they can make good use of items that still have several miles in them. Oh, and I hoovered the carpet TWICE this week - but even the Dyson won't pick up cat whiskers that have woven themselves into the pile! And does anyone have any tips for removing porridge from fur? -- Kate XXXXXX R.C.T.Q Madame Chef des Trolls Lady Catherine, Wardrobe Mistress of the Chocolate Buttons http://www.katedicey.co.uk Click on Kate's Pages and explore! |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
I think you have hit the nail on the head Ms. Tina. I have seen a few poor
little rich kids have moments of epiphany ... rich kids don't often get into social work. -- http://community.webshots.com/user/snigdibbly SNIGDIBBLY ~e~ " / \ http://members.ebay.com/aboutme/snigdibbly. http://www.ebaystores.com/snigdibbly...ox&refid=store "Tina" wrote in message oups.com... "But had poor Mrs Clueless never TRAINED as a social worker?" A person can feel "sympathy" for those less fortunate, they can be trained to deal with behaviors and attitudes - but I honestly do not believe that you can "train" empathy for people in this situation. I don't believe people can honestly understand what it is truly like, unless they have lived it themselves. I know too many people in this area that think just giving a "hand out" or writing a check should be all it takes to help the less fortunate. It's not! For one thing, when I was in this position, I was at times too proud and other times too ashamed to accept money from other people. I wanted to be able to do for myself and provide for my own children without accepting "charity" from others. I was more than willing to work and when I was married to the worthless, abusive alcoholic, I worked three jobs most of the time. There is an old saying that goes something like, "give me a hand UP, not a hand OUT" - this is exactly how I felt during those times. I didn't want to be pitied. I didn't want peoples leftovers. I didn't want to be treated like I was "less than a person" just because I didn't have as nice of clothes as they did or because I sewed my kids clothes. I didn't appreciate being looked down on just because I worked three jobs and when I was at home, I sat on the floor and played with my kids instead of volunteering at church or school or making sure our home was immaculate and kept up with the Jones'es. No, you can't "train" the understanding and the empathy that comes with not having. You can't "train" the mindset that goes along with learning to survive without. You have to live it to believe it. Tina |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
Well said. REminds me of a story by Isaac Bashevis Singer (can't remember
the title) about the concept of "mitzvah", acts of charity. The person who performs a mitzvah is obligated to do it in such a way that the recipient feels he is doing the donor a favor by accepting, so it becomes more of a fair trade. Roberta in D "NightMist" schrieb im Newsbeitrag ... On Tue, 6 Sep 2005 08:47:30 -0500, "SNIGDIBBLY" wrote: For years I was one of the coordinators for the County Community Share Xmas program where we accepted donated Xmas gifts and clothing for Foster Kids and poor kids across the county. I have seen so much waste and abuse. Parents sold the stuff for drugs and alcohol or just threw it out. I found brand new - unwrapped toys - in the garbage during home visits. Many parents signed up for like programs from every agency in the area and got duplicate food baskets and toys and sold them or just threw them out. I will never give a whole turkey dinner again unless I give a cooked turkey because they would let it spoil before they would cook it. There just doesn't seem to be any appreciation for the effort. Most wouldn't even come pick them up and our social workers would have to deliver them or they wouldn't get to the children at all. I have become too cynical. But I enjoy the giving so I do it with the knowledge that it probably won't be used as I wished it to be. I just have to let it go and enjoy the giving. Sure makes me made when people use other people and then abuse their charitible hearts. Snigs, I am not going to even try to excuse the a***oles of the world, because there is no excuse for them. There are indeed plenty of them, on both sides of the giving equation. It is high time some common sense was thrown into the world of charitable giving. Now, so you all know, I give when and what I can when causes come to my attention. More often though, my family and I are on the other side. Yes, we are poor. In fact, one of the jokes is we are "p", 'cause we can't afford the rest of the letters. I know that there are others out there that are much worse off than we are. In fact sometimes I get ****ed off because I know that there are needier people living close by and some charity comes knocking at my door (figuratively and sometimes literally) instead. I usually try to send them in the right direction, but often they are set on who they are going to give to. In my time, we have been gifted with food, clothes, and whatnot, and most of it was about as useful as tits on a boar hog. I have never thrown perfectly good things away, I have always tried to find someone else who needs them, or recycled them into a charitable organization. For example, one of the local churches (unasked) once brought us a turkey dinner for Thanksgiving. Delivered complete with conversion pitch and admonitions about how we were going to go straight to hell if we didn't give up sex, drugs, rock and roll, and our obviously satanic lifestyle. I guess that since we don't have a lot of money that means we are obviously maniacal drug useing minions of satan. Well even if we weren't vegetarians I didn't have the equipment to cook a damn turkey. What the heck was I supposed to do with the thing even if I planned on eating it? Stick it on a fork and toast it over a burner? Put it in the oven in a plastic grocery sack? I'm not even sure it would have fit in my oven. So I gave most of the lot to lady down the road. Even there I had to call the Salvation Army and beg a tinfoil roasting pan for her (she didn't have a phone, and was about as inclined to put her hand out as cut it off). Fortunately they not only gave her the pan but included a whole roll of tinfoil and instructions on how to cook the thing, otherwise she had no better idea of what to do with it than I did. Yeah, "Aunt Sal-ly" rocks! Another time a social worker gave me a bag of 8 or 9 brand new dresses for my then second grader. She thought they would be so cute with tights and rumba pants. Yeah, right. I have never, nor will I ever send a 7 year old child out into January in what amounts to a frilly shirt and stockings. Nor am I inclined to send a 7 year old girl out in a dress that flashes her bottom regardless, even if I could have forced her out the door dressed like that. To say nothing of the fact that I would have had to buy the rumba pants and then a never ending series of tights. (1) The dresses when to Aunt Sal-ly. The number of people who have thought that we would be so grateful to get their trash that we would come and fetch it is astounding. Anytime someone says, 'our widget is broken so we got a new one, but your husband is clever and I am sure he could fix the broken one. Just come and pick it up anytime between noon and 12:01.' I just smile, nod, and walk away. I don't have a car and I am not inclined to walk over to fetch a widget that I have been doing quite well without, and that probably will never work again anyway. There have been times that people have offered me large items that we really did truly need. But we haven't had the means to go fetch them. That has not been good. Especially when they get all angry because they know we need the thing. What the heck am I supposed to do? Pull a carjacking on a moving van? Remember the thread we had on kitchen stoves not long ago? Just last month I was darn near to weeping with frustration because my daughter's landlord offered us an old Chambers gas range in beautiful condition. He had taken on a partner who owned a second hand appliance store and was replaceing all the very old appliances in his apartments with more modern ones. I met this stove, it was beautiful. One of the ones the gas company gave out decades ago to get people to switch from wood or coal to gas. But I didn't have the fifty dollars the partner wanted to shift it, nor could I find anybody to move it for less. My stove is an apartment sized thing with one working burner, one sometimes working burner, and no functional pilots so I have to light the oven from the broiler. I sooo wanted that stove! I s'pose all I am saying is please please think before you give, and think before you condem. That social worker with the dresses gave us no end of grief about DD not wearing them, and other people have gone all superior, taking a "see what happens when you try to do good" attitude when we have not been all happy to recieve useless stuff or able to fetch things we actually needed. If you give a box of tuna helper to the food pantry, please give a couple of cans of tuna with it. Don't assume people will be happy to haul your junk for free just because they are poor. Please don't offer people things without a thought for how they will get them home. That is just cruel, especially if it is something they need. Don't assume that just because they are poor children will be happy with any old thing you want to give them. No ten year old will be happy with a toy meant for a toddler, regardless. Don't assume that everyone knows how to alter clothes that don't fit. Don't get all offended if they do alter clothes that don't fit. Most poor people do not need cable converters, entertainment centers, knick knacks, table linens, or cordless phones. I have been offered all of the above and turned down all but the linens, they were real linen and made some mighty fine shirts, but most people wouldn't know to do that with them. The lady with the cable converter was astounded that I didn't accept it and run right out to get cable. Please! Please! Please! Do not patronize or proselytize. Poor people have as much pride as anyone else. Being given a sermon along with food is something that you can expect at a mission, but not in your own home or at a secular help agency. It is wonderful to try and help the less fortunate. It is not wonderful to expect them to fall down and praise you for it. It is not wonderful to get all huffy when things you give do not get used as you anticipated. NightMist We are doing a whole lot better than we used to. (1) This was a worker who was offended for my child because this child was going to school in hand sewn and made over clothes, of which DD had plenty. -- "To repeat what others have said, requires education; to challenge it, requires brains." -Mary Pettibone Poole |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
Drug addiction is a real problem in our rural communities and unfortunately
our caseloads used to include a lot of those. Being self employed means meth labs in the shed out back for many in our community. Due to the recent growth, we are seeing less and less as we become more and more urban. In the area where I used to do most of my casework they are building a high end, 25 story Condominum - at the cost of over $100 million. You have to have a 7 figure income to be even considered for residency. All the old Warhorse Social Workers laugh up our sleeves about millionaires living in the Avoca, Prairie Creek and Eagle Point area. Rampant incest, neglect, lack of education, generational welfare and home made methamphetemine is being replaced with high end condos. Now that's progress!! -- http://community.webshots.com/user/snigdibbly SNIGDIBBLY ~e~ " / \ http://members.ebay.com/aboutme/snigdibbly. http://www.ebaystores.com/snigdibbly...ox&refid=store "Roberta Zollner" wrote in message ... Well said. REminds me of a story by Isaac Bashevis Singer (can't remember the title) about the concept of "mitzvah", acts of charity. The person who performs a mitzvah is obligated to do it in such a way that the recipient feels he is doing the donor a favor by accepting, so it becomes more of a fair trade. Roberta in D "NightMist" schrieb im Newsbeitrag ... On Tue, 6 Sep 2005 08:47:30 -0500, "SNIGDIBBLY" wrote: For years I was one of the coordinators for the County Community Share Xmas program where we accepted donated Xmas gifts and clothing for Foster Kids and poor kids across the county. I have seen so much waste and abuse. Parents sold the stuff for drugs and alcohol or just threw it out. I found brand new - unwrapped toys - in the garbage during home visits. Many parents signed up for like programs from every agency in the area and got duplicate food baskets and toys and sold them or just threw them out. I will never give a whole turkey dinner again unless I give a cooked turkey because they would let it spoil before they would cook it. There just doesn't seem to be any appreciation for the effort. Most wouldn't even come pick them up and our social workers would have to deliver them or they wouldn't get to the children at all. I have become too cynical. But I enjoy the giving so I do it with the knowledge that it probably won't be used as I wished it to be. I just have to let it go and enjoy the giving. Sure makes me made when people use other people and then abuse their charitible hearts. Snigs, I am not going to even try to excuse the a***oles of the world, because there is no excuse for them. There are indeed plenty of them, on both sides of the giving equation. It is high time some common sense was thrown into the world of charitable giving. Now, so you all know, I give when and what I can when causes come to my attention. More often though, my family and I are on the other side. Yes, we are poor. In fact, one of the jokes is we are "p", 'cause we can't afford the rest of the letters. I know that there are others out there that are much worse off than we are. In fact sometimes I get ****ed off because I know that there are needier people living close by and some charity comes knocking at my door (figuratively and sometimes literally) instead. I usually try to send them in the right direction, but often they are set on who they are going to give to. In my time, we have been gifted with food, clothes, and whatnot, and most of it was about as useful as tits on a boar hog. I have never thrown perfectly good things away, I have always tried to find someone else who needs them, or recycled them into a charitable organization. For example, one of the local churches (unasked) once brought us a turkey dinner for Thanksgiving. Delivered complete with conversion pitch and admonitions about how we were going to go straight to hell if we didn't give up sex, drugs, rock and roll, and our obviously satanic lifestyle. I guess that since we don't have a lot of money that means we are obviously maniacal drug useing minions of satan. Well even if we weren't vegetarians I didn't have the equipment to cook a damn turkey. What the heck was I supposed to do with the thing even if I planned on eating it? Stick it on a fork and toast it over a burner? Put it in the oven in a plastic grocery sack? I'm not even sure it would have fit in my oven. So I gave most of the lot to lady down the road. Even there I had to call the Salvation Army and beg a tinfoil roasting pan for her (she didn't have a phone, and was about as inclined to put her hand out as cut it off). Fortunately they not only gave her the pan but included a whole roll of tinfoil and instructions on how to cook the thing, otherwise she had no better idea of what to do with it than I did. Yeah, "Aunt Sal-ly" rocks! Another time a social worker gave me a bag of 8 or 9 brand new dresses for my then second grader. She thought they would be so cute with tights and rumba pants. Yeah, right. I have never, nor will I ever send a 7 year old child out into January in what amounts to a frilly shirt and stockings. Nor am I inclined to send a 7 year old girl out in a dress that flashes her bottom regardless, even if I could have forced her out the door dressed like that. To say nothing of the fact that I would have had to buy the rumba pants and then a never ending series of tights. (1) The dresses when to Aunt Sal-ly. The number of people who have thought that we would be so grateful to get their trash that we would come and fetch it is astounding. Anytime someone says, 'our widget is broken so we got a new one, but your husband is clever and I am sure he could fix the broken one. Just come and pick it up anytime between noon and 12:01.' I just smile, nod, and walk away. I don't have a car and I am not inclined to walk over to fetch a widget that I have been doing quite well without, and that probably will never work again anyway. There have been times that people have offered me large items that we really did truly need. But we haven't had the means to go fetch them. That has not been good. Especially when they get all angry because they know we need the thing. What the heck am I supposed to do? Pull a carjacking on a moving van? Remember the thread we had on kitchen stoves not long ago? Just last month I was darn near to weeping with frustration because my daughter's landlord offered us an old Chambers gas range in beautiful condition. He had taken on a partner who owned a second hand appliance store and was replaceing all the very old appliances in his apartments with more modern ones. I met this stove, it was beautiful. One of the ones the gas company gave out decades ago to get people to switch from wood or coal to gas. But I didn't have the fifty dollars the partner wanted to shift it, nor could I find anybody to move it for less. My stove is an apartment sized thing with one working burner, one sometimes working burner, and no functional pilots so I have to light the oven from the broiler. I sooo wanted that stove! I s'pose all I am saying is please please think before you give, and think before you condem. That social worker with the dresses gave us no end of grief about DD not wearing them, and other people have gone all superior, taking a "see what happens when you try to do good" attitude when we have not been all happy to recieve useless stuff or able to fetch things we actually needed. If you give a box of tuna helper to the food pantry, please give a couple of cans of tuna with it. Don't assume people will be happy to haul your junk for free just because they are poor. Please don't offer people things without a thought for how they will get them home. That is just cruel, especially if it is something they need. Don't assume that just because they are poor children will be happy with any old thing you want to give them. No ten year old will be happy with a toy meant for a toddler, regardless. Don't assume that everyone knows how to alter clothes that don't fit. Don't get all offended if they do alter clothes that don't fit. Most poor people do not need cable converters, entertainment centers, knick knacks, table linens, or cordless phones. I have been offered all of the above and turned down all but the linens, they were real linen and made some mighty fine shirts, but most people wouldn't know to do that with them. The lady with the cable converter was astounded that I didn't accept it and run right out to get cable. Please! Please! Please! Do not patronize or proselytize. Poor people have as much pride as anyone else. Being given a sermon along with food is something that you can expect at a mission, but not in your own home or at a secular help agency. It is wonderful to try and help the less fortunate. It is not wonderful to expect them to fall down and praise you for it. It is not wonderful to get all huffy when things you give do not get used as you anticipated. NightMist We are doing a whole lot better than we used to. (1) This was a worker who was offended for my child because this child was going to school in hand sewn and made over clothes, of which DD had plenty. -- "To repeat what others have said, requires education; to challenge it, requires brains." -Mary Pettibone Poole |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Katrina Relief Quilts Question | Betsy Ross | Quilting | 7 | September 4th 05 04:04 PM |
Katrina quilts: Need quick answer | Betsy Ross | Quilting | 2 | September 4th 05 03:18 PM |
Katrina quilts | CNY/VAstitcher | Quilting | 30 | September 4th 05 02:11 PM |
UPDATE: Quilts for Tsunami Orphans | Kathy (in Alaska) | Quilting | 0 | January 3rd 05 07:02 PM |
Shelter Animal Quilts | Tim & Jill Pochik | Quilting | 7 | August 19th 03 04:18 AM |